The problem with Facebook Like is that it breaks Activity Streams and instead tries be the sole provider of social context.
Currently, activity updates are tightly bound to the service in which they were created. In order to share with others, the choices are blunt – annoy all your Facebook friends with game updates, annoy all your twitter followers with 4square checkins. By giving activity streams a standard vocabulary and metadata, applications will gain the capability to create more refined – and contexually relevant – posting choices and reading filters.
But that’s what Facebook’s “Like” gets rid of. See, there’s an alternative vision about social context. And that is that Facebook is your one and only source of context. Thomas Vanderwal suggests, in the discussion of Facebook’s recent announcement, that Facebook is not doing such a great job of this today: “The social graph is dangerous without context and much more dangerous w/ partial context.” ActivityStreams fosters competition among services that want to provide social context of various sorts, and Like forecloses that competition.
Elias Bizannes does the technical analysis to support this conclusion in an excellent post on the Data Portability project blog which analyzes the open-ness of Facebook’s Open Graph Protocol. Bizannes writes that:
the proposed page header metadata “a play to increase the quantity of semantic data on the web and then capture social gestures (aka “Likes”) made against those concrete semantic objects – think a web-wide recommendation engine. This is a big step forward for Tim Berners-Lee’s vision of the semantic web.
Currently, however, these gestures are submitted to FB’s proprietary database using proprietary API calls. This was not the most open way to execute on this functionality. Instead, these gestures could be written out to a site-specific Activity Stream that can then be indexed by any web-crawler.
There is a simple way for Facebook to remedy this situation, which is to support the Activity Streams standard for like updates. In this way, Facebook could compete to actually be the superior provider of social context – it has a major opportunity here – without closing off competition to other sites, tools and services.
If Facebook doesn’t do this, the challenge for those who’ll benefit from competition is to make it very easy to support standard activity streams – and then use that data to actually do a better job than Facebook at supporting the social desires of users
The problem with Facebook Like is that it breaks Activity Streams & tries be the sole provider of social context http://bit.ly/9pFGYe
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
Adina has this right; I’m hoping that Facebook has enough self coincidence to continue supporting Activity Streams instead of making upsolipsistic
This comment was originally posted on FriendFeed
The problem with Facebook Like http://j.mp/ducMCt
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
Louis Gray: The problem with Facebook Like: http://bit.ly/9NgHFd
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
The problem with Facebook Like http://bit.ly/dh98Io By @alevin
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
RT @Avinio: The problem with Facebook Like http://bit.ly/dh98Io By @alevin
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
The problem with Facebook Like http://j.mp/9FhWiH
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
RT @thomaspower: Liked “The problem with Facebook Like” http://ff.im/-joyFk
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
RT @Avinio: The problem with Facebook Like http://bit.ly/dh98Io By @alevin
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
RT @alevin: The problem with Facebook Like is that it breaks Activity Streams & tries be the sole provider of social context http://bit …
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
RT @thomaspower: Liked “The problem with Facebook Like” http://ff.im/-joyFk
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
RT @Avinio: The problem with Facebook Like http://bit.ly/dh98Io By @alevin
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
“The problem with Facebook Like” – http://j.mp/bWcKiA
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
“The problem with Facebook Like” – http://j.mp/bWcKiA /via @Jesse #activitystreams
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
RT @Jesse: “The problem with Facebook Like” – http://j.mp/bWcKiA
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
Facebook ‘Like’ .. breaks Activity Streams and.. tries to be the sole provider of social context http://bit.ly/dadFMb #fb
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
#SemNews : BookBlog » Blog Archive » The problem with Facebook Like – Adina … http://bit.ly/993CBs
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
RT @Jesse: “The problem with Facebook Like” – http://j.mp/bWcKiA
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
The problem with Facebook Like http://goo.gl/fb/5raTF
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
Currently Browsing: http://is.gd/bIgth
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
RT @Jesse: “The problem with Facebook Like” – http://j.mp/bWcKiA
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
The problem with facebook ‘Like’ http://www.alevin.com/?p=2159
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
The problem with Facebook Like | BookBlog – http://bit.ly/aq8But (Share Credit: @louisgray) #Facebook
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
RT @Jesse: “The problem with Facebook Like” – http://j.mp/bWcKiA
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
The problem with Facebook Like is that it breaks Activity Streams & tries be the sole provider of social context http://bit.ly/9pFGYe
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
RT @alevin: The problem with Facebook Like is that it breaks Activity Streams & tries be the sole provider of social context http://bit. …
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
RT @alevin: The problem with Facebook Like is that it breaks Activity Streams & tries be the sole provider of social context http://bit. …
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
RT @alevin: The problem with Facebook Like is it breaks Activity Streams & tries be the sole provider of social context http://bit.ly/9pFGYe
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
“The social graph is dangerous without context and much more dangerous w/ partial context.” @eliasbiz quoted too! http://icio.us/g42wo1
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
RT @alevin: The problem with Facebook Like is that it breaks Activity Streams & tries be the sole provider of social context http://bit. …
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
The problem with Facebook Like is that it breaks Activity Streams & tries be the sole provider of social context… http://ff.im/-jqfeG
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
The problem with Facebook Like – Adina Levin’s weblog:
Linkorama : The problem with Facebook Like – Adina Lev.. http://bit.ly/9gH4OI
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
The problem with Facebook Like – Adina Levin’s weblog:
Linkorama : The problem with Facebook Like – Adina Levin’s… http://bit.ly/9NgHFd
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
RT @plingyplang: “The social graph is dangerous without context and much more dangerous w/ partial context.” @eliasbiz quoted too! http://icio.us/g42wo1
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
Like this: The problem with Facebook Like http://bit.ly/9pFGYe #SxD #UX
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
RT: @semanticwill: Like this: The problem with Facebook Like http://bit.ly/9pFGYe #SxD #UX
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
Like this: The problem with Facebook Like http://bit.ly/9pFGYe #SxD #UX /via @semanticwill
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
FB “Like” breaks activity streams RT @ semanticwill Like this: The problem with Facebook Like http://bit.ly/9pFGYe #SxD #UX
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
RT @semanticwill: Like this: The problem with Facebook Like http://bit.ly/9pFGYe #SxD #UX
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
RT @semanticwill Like this: The problem with Facebook Like http://bit.ly/9pFGYe #SxD #UX
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
RT @semanticwill Like this: The problem with Facebook Like http://bit.ly/9pFGYe #SxD #UX
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
RT @aaroni268 RT @semanticwill Like this: The problem with Facebook Like http://bit.ly/9pFGYe #SxD #UX
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
food for thought (2)
This comment was originally posted on FriendFeed